Forest Resources in the Performance of Mexican Community Forest Enterprises in a Vertical Integration System

Author(s): Juan Regino Maldonado, Wen Yali, Frederick Cubbage, Patricia Regino Maldonado

The objective of the research was to analyze the relationship between the use and control of forest resources as measured by volume sold (m3/year), volume harvested (m3/ha), and timber production area under forest management (ha) and the performance as measured by profits ($/m3) of community forest enterprises in Mexico under a vertical integration system, from perspectives theory of the firm and new institutional economics. The study is based on an analysis of data from a sampling of 30 enterprises in 12 states in the country in 2011. The research hypothesis states that the use and control of forest resources is positively associated with the profits of the enterprises. The study used linear regression to test the hypothesis. The study concludes that for the sample, the volume harvested m3/ha, was associated positively and significantly with harvesting profits $/m3. Whereas, the timber production area (ha) and volume sold m3/year were associated positively, but not significantly with profits $/m3 of enterprises. At the group level, the volume harvested m3/ha was positively associated with harvesting profits ($/m3) of type III (timber growing and harvesting) enterprises, while volume sold (m3/year) was associated positively with harvesting profits ($/m3) of type IV (vertically integrated timber growing through sawmilling) enterprises. The statistical results were not significant. This suggests no definite conclusions can be made on the general and by size, use and control of forest resources regression results. However, the results are a first approach to understanding the performance of enterprises vertically integrated under a structure of communal government.

Community forest enterprises, vertical integration, new institutional economics, theory of the firm, resource-based view, common-pool resources

1. Antinori C, Rausser GC (2008) Ownership and control in Mexico´s community forestry sector. Economic Development and cultural change 57(1):101-136
2. Antinori C (2007) Integración vertical en las empresas forestales comunitarias de Oaxaca. In Bray D, Merino L, Barry D (eds) Los bosques comunitarios de México: manejo sustentable de paisajes forestales, 1ra edn. INE-SEMARNAT, Mexico, pp 303-342
3. Antinori CM, Bray DB (2005) Community forest enterprises as entrepreneurial firms: economic and institutional perspectives from México. World Dev 33(9):1529-1543. doi:10.1016/j.worlddev.2004.10.011
4. Antinori CM (2000) Vertical integration in Mexican common property forests. Dissertation, University of California
5. Bain J (1954) Economics of scale, concentration, and the conditions of entry in twenty manufacturing industries. Am Econ Rev (44):15-34
6. Barney J (1991) Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage. J Manage 17(1):99-120
7. Barney J (1986) Strategic factor markets: Expectations, luck, and business strategy. Manage Sci 32(10):656-665
8. Bharadwaj SG, Varadarajan PR, Fahy J (1993) Sustainable competitive advantage in service industries: a conceptual model and research propositions. J Marketing 57(4):83-99
9. Boyce JK, Shelly BG (2003). Natural assets: Democratizing environmental ownership. Island Press, Washington, DC
10. Bray DB, Antinori C, Torres-Rojo JM (2006) The Mexican model of community forest management. Forest Policy Econ 8:470-484. doi:10.1016/j.forpol.2005.08.002
11. Bray DB, Merino-Pérez L, Barry D (2005) The community forests of México: Managing for sustainable landscapes. University of Texas Press, Austin, Texas, USA
12. Brush CG, Chaganti R (1999) Businesses without glamour? an analysis of resources on performance by size and age in small service and retail firms. J Bus Venturing 14(3):233-257
13. Caloghirou Y, Kastelli I, Tsakanikas A (2004) Internal capabilities and external knowledge sources: complements or substitutes for innovative performance? Technovation 24(1):29-39. doi:10.1016/S0166-4972(02)00051-2
14. Changhai W, Wen Y, Jing W (2014) The socio-economic effect of the reform of the collective forest rights system in Suthern China: a case of Tonggu County, Jiangxi Province. Small Scale For. doi.org/10.1007/s11842-014-9263-9
15. Coase RH (1960) The problem of social cost. J Law Econ 3(1):1-44
16. Coase RH (1937) The nature of the firm. Economica New Ser 4:386-405
17. Comisión Nacional Forestal (CONAFOR) (2013) Logros y perspectivas del desarrollo forestal en México 2007-2012. Coordinación general de producción y productividad. http://www.conafor.gob.mx:8080/biblioteca/ver.aspx?articulo=489
18. Comisión Nacional Forestal (CONAFOR) (2010) Productos maderables certificados, catálogo 2010, México, D. F. FSC. http://www.conafor.gob.mx/biblioteca/Productos-maderables-certificados-Catalogo.pdf
19. Comisión Nacional Forestal (CONAFOR) (2001) Programa estratégico forestal para México 2025. Informe final. http://www.conafor.gob.mx:8080/documentos/ver.aspx?articulo=307&grupo=4
20. Cubbage F, Davis R, Rodríguez PD, Frey G, Mollenhauer R, Kraus EY, González HI, Albarrán HA, Salazar CA, Chemor SD (2013) Competitividad y acceso a mercados de empresas forestales comunitarias en México. http://www.conafor.gob.mx:8080/documentos/docs/22/4807Competitividad%20y%20Acceso%20a%20Mercados%20de%20EFC%20en%20Mexico.pdf
21. Cubbage F, Koesbanda S, Mac Donagh P, Rubilar R, Balmelli G, Morales OV, De la Torre R, Murara M, Hoeflich VA, Kotze H, Gonzalez R, Carrerro O, Frey G, Adams T, Turner J, Lord R, Huang J, MacIntyre C, McGinley K, Abt R, Phillips R (2010) Global timber investments, wood costs, regulation, and risk. Biomass Bioener 34(12):1667-1678. doi:10.1016/j.biombioe.2010.05.008
22. Cubbage F, Mac Donagh P, Sawinski J, Rubilar R, Donoso P, Ferreira A, Hoeflich V, Morales OV, Ferreira G, Balmelli G, Siry J, Báez M, Alvarez J (2007) Timber investment returns for selected plantations and native forests in South America and the Southern United States. New Forests 33(3):237-255. doi: 10.1007/s11056-006-9025-4
23. Donovan J, Stoian D, Poole N (2008) Global review of rural community enterprises: The long and winding road to creating viable businesses and potential shortcuts. CATIE. http://orton.catie.ac.cr/repdoc/A2720I/A2720I.PDF
24. Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) (2010) Global forest resource assessment 2010. Main report. http://www.fao.org/docrep/013/i1757e/i1757e.pdf
25. Fudenberg D, Tirole J (2005) Noncooperative game theory for industrial organization: An introduction and overview. In Schmalensee R, Willing RD (eds) Handbook of Industrial Organization volume 1, North-Holland, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, pp 259-328
26. Garibay C (2007) El dilema corporativo del comunalismo forestal. Desacatos, 23:251-274.
27. Gómez I, Méndez E (2007) Association of forest communities of Peten, Guatemala. Context, accomplishments and challenges. http://www.cifor.org/acm/download/pub/grassroot/Peten%20guatemala_eng%20All.pdf
28. Grant RM (1996) Prospering in dynamically-competitive environments: organizational capability as knowledge integration. Organ Sci 7(4):375-387
29. Grant RM (1991) The resource-based theory of competitive advantage: implications for strategy formulation. Calif Manage Rev 33(3):114-135
30. Hall R (1993) A framework linking intangible resources and capabilities to sustainable competitive advantage. Strategic Manage J 14 (8):607-618
31. Hall R (1992) The strategy analysis of intangible resources. Strategic Manage J 13 (2):135-144
32. Hall M, Weiss L (1967) Firm size and profitability. Rev Econ Stat 49(3):319-331
33. Hawawini G, Subramanian V, Verdin P (2003) Is performance driven by industry-or firm-specific factors? a new look at the evidence. Strategic Manage J 24(1):1-16. doi: 10.1002/smj.278
34. Hansen G, Wernerfelt B (1989) Determinants of firm performance: the relative importance of economic and organizational factors. Strategic Manage J 10(5):399-411. doi: 10.1002/smj.4250100502
35. Hardin G (1968) The tragedy of the commons. Science 62(3859):1243-1248
36. Hatch NW, Dyer JH (2004) Human capital and learning as a source of sustainable competitive advantage. Strategic Manage J 25(12):1155-1178. doi: 10.1002/smj.421
37. Holmstrom BR, Tirole J (2005) The theory of the firm. In Schmalensee R, Willing RD (eds) Handbook of Industrial Organization volume 1, North-Holland, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, pp 61-134
38. Harrigan KR (1985) Vertical integration and corporate strategy. Aca Manage J 28(2):397-425
39. Madrid L, Núñez JM, Quiroz G, Rodríguez Y (2009) La propiedad forestal social en México. Investigación ambiental 1(2):179-196
40. Mahemba CM, De Bruijn EJ (2003) Innovation activities by small and medium-sized manufacturing enterprises in Tanzania. Creativity Inno Manage 12(3):162-173. doi: 10.1111/1467-8691.00279
41. Mahoney JT (1992) The choice of organizational form: vertical financial ownership versus other methods of vertical integration. Strategic Manage J 13(8):559-584
42. Mauri AJ, Michaels MP (1998) Firm an industry effects within strategic management: an empirical examination. Strategic Manage J 19(3):211-219
43. Merino-Pérez L, Segura-Warnholtz G (2005) Forest and conservation policies and their impacts on forest communities in Mexico. In Bray DB, Merino-Pérez L, Barry D (eds) The community forests of Mexico: Managing for Sustainable Landscapes, University of Texas Press, Austin, Texas, USA, pp 49-69
44. Miller D (2004) Firm´s technological resources and the performance effects of diversification: a longitudinal study. Strategic Manage J 25(11):1097-1119
45. Muñoz-Piña C, de Janvry A, Sadoulet E (2003) Recrafting rights over common. Property resources in Mexico. Econ Dev Cult Change 52(1):129-158
46. McDaniel JM (2003) Community-based forestry and timber certification in southeast Bolivia. Small scale For Econ, Manage Policy 2(3):327-341
47. McEvily S, Chakravarthy B (2002) The perspective of knowledge-based advantage: an empirical test for product performance and technological knowledge. Strategic Manage J 23(4):285-375. doi: 10.1002/smj.223
48. McGahan AM, Porter ME (1997) How much does industry matter, really? Strategic Management J 18(S1):15-30. doi: 10.1002/(SICI)1097-0266(199707)18:1+<15::AID-SMJ916>3.0.CO;2-1
49. Nolan TM (2001) Community based forest management: Commercial harvesting of the rainforest of Indonesia. Int For Rev 3(3):231-235
50. North DC (1990) Institutions, institutional change and economic performance. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
51. Ostrom E (2002) Reformulating the commons. Ambiente & Sociedade V(10):1-22
52. Ostrom E (1990) Governing the commons. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
53. Perry MK (2005) Vertical integration: Determinants and effects. In Schmalensee R, Willing RD (eds) Handbook of Industrial Organization volume 1, North-Holland, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, pp 183-255
54. Porter ME (1985) Competitive advantage: Creating and sustaining superior performance. Free Press, New York
55. Porter ME (1980) Competitive Strategy: Techniques for analysing industries and competitors. Free Press, New York
56. Putz FE, Pinard MA, Fredericksen TS, Peña-Claros M (2004) Forest science and the BOLFOR experience: Lessons learned about natural forest management in Bolivia. In Zarin JD, Alavalapati JR, Putz F, Schmink M (eds) working forests in the neotropics: Conservation through sustainable management? Columbia University Press, New York, 64–96.
57. Prescott JE, Kohli AK, Venkatraman N (1986) The market share-profitability relationship: an empirical assessment of major assertions and contradictions. Strategic Manage J 7(4):377-394
58. Reinganum JF (2005) The timing innovation: research, development and diffusion. In Schmalensee R, Willing RD (eds) Handbook of Industrial Organization volume 1, North-Holland, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, pp 849-908
59. Restrepo JH, Lopera JF, Rodríguez SM (2007) La integración vertical en el sistema de salud colombiano. Rev Econ Inst 9(17):279-308
60. Rumelt RP (1991) How much does industry matter? Strategic Manage J 12(3):167-185
61. Rumelt RP, Schendel D, Teece DJ (1991) Strategic management and economics. Strategic Manage J 12(winter):5-29
62. Segura-Warnholtz G (2014) Quince años de políticas públicas para la acción colectiva en comunidades forestales. Rev Mex Sociol 76(5):105-135
63. Secretaría de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales-Instituto Nacional de Ecología y Cambio Climático (SEMARNAT-INECC) 2012 México uinta comunicación nacional ante la Convención Marco de las Naciones Unidas sobre el cambio climático. INECC, México, D. F. http://www2.inecc.gob.mx/publicaciones/download/685.pdf
64. Secretaría de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales (SEMARNAT) 2014 Anuario estadístico de la producción forestal 2014. Dirección general de gestión forestal y de suelos. Dirección del registro y del sistema nacional de gestión forestal. México, D. F. http://www.semarnat.gob.mx/sites/default/files/documentos/forestal/anuarios/anuario_2013.pdf
65. Schlager E, Ostrom E (1992) Property-rights regimes and natural resources: A conceptual analysis. Land Economics 68(3):249-262
66. Scherr SJ, White A, Kaimowitz D (2003) A new agenda for conservation and poverty reduction. Making markets work for low-income producers. Forest Trends, CIFOR, Washington, D. C. http://www.cifor.org/publications/pdf_files/Books/A%20New%20Agenda.pdf
67. Schroeder RG, Bates KA, Junttila MA (2002) A resource-based view of manufacturing strategy and the relationship to manufacturing performance. Strategic Manage J 23(2):105-117. doi: 10.1002/smj.213
68. Shen J, Han X, Wen Y, Xie Y (2013) Comparison of the forest tenure in Brazil and China. Can Soc Sci 9(6):94-99
69. Shen Y, Zhnag Y, Xu X, Zhu Z, Jiang C (2009) Towards decentralization and privatization of China’s collective forestlands. Int For Rev 11(4):28-35. doi.org/10.1505/ifor.11.4.456
70. Schmalensee R (1985) Do markets differ much. Am Econ Rev 75(3):341-351
71. Schmalensee R, Willig RD (2005) Handbook of Industrial Organization volume 1, North-Holland, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
72. Stoian D, Donovan J (2010) Poverty-environment dividends of rural community enterprises: insights from a cross-sectoral study in Latin America and the Caribbean. CATIE. http://orton.catie.ac.cr/repdoc/A7713I/A7713I.PDF
73. Stone R, D´Andrea C (2001) Tropical forests and the human spirit: journeys to the brink of hope. University of California Press. Bekerley and Los Angeles, USA
74. Tirole J (1989) The theory of industrial organization, MIT Press Cambridge, Cambridge MA
75. Villavicencio G, Hansen E, Bliss J (2012) Factors impacting marketplace success of community forest enterprises: The case of TIP muebles, Oaxaca, Mexico. Small-scale For 11(3):339-363. doi: 10.1007/s11842-011-9188-5
76. Williamson OE (1981) The economics of organizations: the transaction cost approach. The Am J Sociol 87(3):548-577
77. Williamson OE (1975) Markets and hierarchies: analysis and antitrust implications. Free Press, New York
78. Wilshusen PR (2003) Negotiating devolution: community conflict, structural power, and local forest management in Quintana Roo, Mexico. Dissertation, University of Michigan
79. Wiklund J, Shepherd D (2003) Knowledge-based resources, entrepreneurial orientation, and the performance of small and medium-sized businesses. Strategic Manage J 24(13):1307-1314. doi: 10.1002/smj.360
80. White A, Martin A (2002) Who owns the world’s forests? Forest tenure and public forests in transition. Forest Trends, Center for International Environmental Law, Washintong, D.C.
81. http://www.forest-trends.org/documents/files/doc_159.pdf
82. Xie Y, Wen Y, Zhang Y, Li X (2013) Impact of property rights reform on household forest management investment: an empirical study of southern China. Forest Policy Econ 34:73-78. doi:10.1016/j.forpol.2012.12.002
83. Yli-Renko H, Autio E, Sapienza HJ (2001) Social capital, knowledge acquisition, and knowledge exploitation in young technology–based firms. Strategic Manage J 22(6):587-613. doi: 10.1002/smj.183
84. Zhang Y, Uusivuori J, Kuuluvainen (2000) Impacts of economic reforms on rural forestry in China. Forest Policy Econ 1(1):27-40
85. Zhang Y (2002) The impacts of economic reform on the efficiency of silviculture: a non-parametric approach. Environ Dev Econ 7(1):107-122